MDF Shutters or Wood Shutters - Which Material is Best?

Selecting the right shutters for your home is more than just about style; it’s about finding the perfect balance between functionality, aesthetics, and longevity.

In the realm of shutters, wood and MDF (Medium-Density Fiberboard) stand out as popular choices. Both are high-quality shutters that allow you to control the influx of natural light into your home whilst offering a broad range of aesthetic appeal. However, each option brings its own unique set of benefits and considerations.

So, whether you’re a homeowner looking to upgrade your space, an interior design enthusiast exploring bespoke shutters, or a DIYer planning your next project, this blog post will guide you through the key differences between wooden shutters and MDF shutters, helping you make an informed decision so you can pick the window shutters that complement your windows perfectly.

Let’s start by looking at each option in more detail

What are MDF shutters?

MDF shutters are made from an engineered wood composite, finished with a durable polymer coating. They offer an excellent balance of quality and value, making them a compelling choice for many homeowners.

Pros of MDF shutters

Cost-effective: One of the main benefits of MDF shutters is their price. On average, they are approximately 25% cheaper than their wooden counterparts, providing a long-lasting solution without the hefty price tag.
Durability: With a hardwearing and easy-to-clean polymer finish, MDF shutters are highly resistant to daily wear and tear such as bumps, chips, and scratches.
Aesthetics: Despite being engineered, MDF shutters boast a natural appearance, closely mirroring the look and feel of real wood shutters.

Check Shutters Gallery

Cons of MDF shutters

Limited customisation: MDF shutters come in a selection of popular colours, but lack the option for custom stains or finishes.
Size constraints: They may not be suitable for large windows or designs requiring numerous bi-folding panels due to weight and support issues.
Restricted designs: Certain design options, such as solid panels or shaped shutters, are not available in MDF.

What are wooden shutters?

Crafted from natural sources like Basswood, wood shutters exude elegance and offer unparalleled versatility in design and finishing options. They are considered a premium shutter choice, ideal for adding value and charm to any home.

Pros of real wood shutters

Structural strength: Wood’s superior internal structure makes it ideal for large shutters or designs featuring multiple bi-folding panels.
Custom finishes: Wood shutters can be painted or stained, allowing for an extensive range of colour options and natural grain finishes.
Lightweight: Wood shutters are lighter than their MDF counterparts, facilitating easier handling and operation.

Cons of wood shutters

Maintenance: Being prone to damages such as bumps, chips, and scratches, wood shutters require careful handling and occasional touch-ups.
Moisture sensitivity: Over time, the paint finish on wood shutters can develop cracks due to exposure to dampness or humidity.
Higher cost: Wooden shutters are a premium option, and their price reflects this.

How do they compare?

When juxtaposing MDF and wood shutters, several aspects come into play:

Price comparison

MDF shutters offer a more budget-friendly solution without significantly compromising on the look or durability, making them a preferred choice for many homeowners.
Weight comparison

MDF’s lighter weight advantage is noteworthy for larger installations, though wood’s lightweight nature ensures operability isn’t compromised.
Aesthetic comparison

While both materials can achieve a high-end look, wood shutters offer the authenticity of natural grain patterns, appealing to those desiring a more organic aesthetic.
Durability comparison

Wood shutters stand out for their ability to withstand temperature changes and moisture better than MDF, making them suitable for various environments.

Which shutters are best for me?

Each option brings many benefits and so your choice between MDF and wood shutters will largely depend on your specific needs, preferences, and budget.

Shutters for Bedroom Shutters for Kitchen Shutters for Bathroom

For small to medium-sized windows in relatively stable environments, MDF shutters present a cost-effective and durable option. On the other hand, for larger windows or spaces exposed to fluctuating temperatures and moisture levels, wood shutters offer greater durability and design flexibility.

FAQ

Q: Can I customise the colour of MDF shutters?

A: While MDF shutters come in a range of popular colours, they cannot be custom stained or painted.

Q: Is a wooden shutter suitable for a humid environment like a bathroom or wet rooms?

A: Wood shutters are more susceptible to moisture damage and may not be an ideal choice for rooms with high humidity levels.

Q: Can I install MDF shutters myself?

A: While DIY installation is possible, we recommend consulting a professional for optimal results and safety.

Q: Do both types of shutters offer the same level of insulation?

A: Yes, both MDF and wood shutters provide excellent insulation. The solid panel that they are composed of acts as a physical barrier, helping to regulate the temperature and noise levels in your home. Perfect for the colder months or if you live on a busy road.

Conclusion

Both wood and MDF shutters have their merits, making them viable options for enhancing your home’s interior. Each elevates the aesthetics of your home whilst giving you complete control over light and privacy.

By considering factors such as cost, appearance, durability, and maintenance, you can select the best shutters to meet your aesthetic and functional requirements.

Get a free quote today

If you’re looking to make an informed choice about shutters for your home, Lifestyle Windows and Shutters is here to help.

We have a wide collection of plantation shutters in both MDF and natural wood and our team of experts can help you make a decision on which would be the best choice for your home, taking into account your requirements and budget.